MANORVILLE, NY — Long Islanders have spoken — and chosen their pick for the best bagel of 2024.
According to the Best of LI contest, presented by Bethpage Federal Credit Union, the 2024 winner for Best Bagel is Blazin Bagel and Deli, located at 287 Wading River Road in Manorville.
“Blazin Bagel and Deli creates an exceptional bagel experience, setting a new standard for perfection in this Long Island breakfast staple,” the Best of LI page said. “These handcrafted bagels are a testament to quality and authenticity. Boiled and baked to perfection, Blazin Bagel's creations feature a delightful balance of chewiness and crunch, creating the perfect bagel texture. The menu features a variety of flavors, from classic plain to all bagels in unique options like blueberry and Asiago. Paired with a selection of handcrafted spreads and toppings, each bagel is a culinary delight. Blazin Bagel's commitment to freshness and flavor ensures that every bite is a savory journey, making it a favorite destination for bagel lovers looking for a great breakfast or brunch experience.”
Speaking with Patch, Blazin Bagel owner Dan Fusaro said he was proud of the honor. “It's great,” he said. “It's very hard work.”
Fusaro, who opened his business two and a half years ago, said all of his bagels are made from scratch, on premises. “We take pride in our bagels,” he said. “They're New York bagels—Brooklyn-style, old-school bagels, boiled and baked.”
His parents once lived in Brooklyn, Fusaro added.
Customer favorites at the store include egg bagels, she said. “These sell a lot.”
Fusaro said he has also done “bagel revelations” and last year, he had a contest where the winners were based on “Willy Wonka,” where two winners won 30 bagels each.
Plus, the shop has a signature bagel, he said: “Our rainbow bagels are like no other. We're proud of them. Nobody makes rainbow bagels like we do.”
